Carrier comparison
AmTrust Financial vs. Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) for Workers' Comp
AmTrust Financial and Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) are two workers' compensation carriers we can quote side by side through Provident Financial Group, an independent agency. On one application we present every carrier we can access, ranked, so you can compare and purchase online.
AmTrust Financial and Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) take different approaches to workers' compensation for small businesses. The details below come directly from each carrier's record on this site — we present the facts we have verified so you can compare them directly, then request quotes through our agency. We do not rank one carrier above another; we show every option side by side.
When you submit one application through US Workers Comp Insure, we request quotes from every carrier we can access for your class code and state, including both AmTrust Financial and Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) where each carrier's appetite and underwriting criteria allow it. A carrier that declines is shown honestly rather than hidden, and a licensed agent at Provident Financial Group can explain why and what alternatives remain.
The two carriers
AmTrust Financial
AmTrust Financial Services is a privately held small-commercial specialist founded in 1998, rated A- (Excellent) by AM Best. It is one of the largest writers of small-business workers' comp in the U.S., known for online policy issuance and a pay-as-you-go payment program.
- AM Best rating:
- A- (Excellent) (as of 2025-10)
- How it’s quoted:
- Through our agency, alongside other carriers
Workers’ comp highlights
- AM Best Financial Strength Rating of A- (Excellent); Long-Term ICR a- (Excellent), affirmed October 10, 2025
- One of the largest writers of small-business workers' compensation in the U.S.
- Streamlined online policy issuance built for small commercial accounts
- Pay-as-you-go premium payment program tied to payroll
- Founded 1998 in New York; operational headquarters in Cleveland, Ohio
- Privately held since going private in 2018
Typical fit
- Small businesses with modest payroll seeking fast, streamlined issuance
- Employers across a wide range of lower-hazard and moderate-hazard class codes
- Businesses that want pay-as-you-go billing
- Accounts where a specialist small-commercial carrier's appetite may fit better than a large-account carrier's
Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY)
Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) was founded in 1962 and has been a member of Tokio Marine Group since 2008. PHLY's insurance subsidiaries carry an AM Best Financial Strength Rating of A++ (Superior), affirmed October 23, 2025, and the company is known for niche-industry specialty programs.
- AM Best rating:
- A++ (Superior) (as of 2025-10)
- How it’s quoted:
- Through our agency, alongside other carriers
Workers’ comp highlights
- AM Best Financial Strength Rating of A++ (Superior); Long-Term ICR aa+ (Superior), affirmed October 23, 2025
- Founded 1962; headquartered in Bala Cynwyd, Pennsylvania
- Member of Tokio Marine Group since a 2008 acquisition
- Known for specialty programs serving niche industries such as nonprofit and human-services organizations
- Workers' compensation typically offered as part of tailored package programs
- Distributed through independent agents
Typical fit
- Nonprofit, human-services, religious, and other niche-industry organizations
- Employers whose operations fit one of PHLY's specialty program niches
- Businesses that want workers' comp packaged with liability and other lines specific to their industry
- Accounts seeking a highly rated, long-established specialty carrier
Compare up to 10 carriers in minutes.
One application goes out to every carrier we can access for your class of business. You get a ranked comparison you can review and purchase online — with a licensed agent available whenever you want one.
Mon–Fri, 8:00am–6:00pm ET · Independent agency licensed in 23 states
Side by side
| Attribute | AmTrust Financial | Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) |
|---|---|---|
| Carrier | AmTrust Financial | Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) |
| AM Best financial strength rating | A- (Excellent) (as of 2025-10) | A++ (Superior) (as of 2025-10) |
| How it's quoted | Through our agency, alongside other carriers | Through our agency, alongside other carriers |
| Typical account fit | Small businesses with modest payroll seeking fast, streamlined issuance; Employers across a wide range of lower-hazard and moderate-hazard class codes; Businesses that want pay-as-you-go billing | Nonprofit, human-services, religious, and other niche-industry organizations; Employers whose operations fit one of PHLY's specialty program niches; Businesses that want workers' comp packaged with liability and other lines specific to their industry |
| Overview | AmTrust Financial Services is a privately held small-commercial specialist founded in 1998, rated A- (Excellent) by AM Best. It is one of the largest writers of small-business workers' comp in the U.S., known for online policy issuance and a pay-as-you-go payment program. | Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) was founded in 1962 and has been a member of Tokio Marine Group since 2008. PHLY's insurance subsidiaries carry an AM Best Financial Strength Rating of A++ (Superior), affirmed October 23, 2025, and the company is known for niche-industry specialty programs. |
How each is quoted through our agency
AmTrust Financial
Quoted through our agency alongside other carriers; we present every option side by side so you can compare and purchase online.
Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY)
Quoted through our agency alongside other carriers; we present every option side by side so you can compare and purchase online.
The bottom line
There is no single "best" carrier between AmTrust Financial and Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY). The right fit depends on your operation, class codes, payroll and how each carrier's underwriting appetite lines up with your account — and that is exactly what one application, sent to every carrier we can access, is built to show you.
Rather than choosing one carrier up front, US Workers Comp Insure requests quotes from every carrier we can access for your state and class code, including AmTrust Financial and Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) where each carrier's criteria allow it, and presents them ranked side by side. A carrier that declines is shown honestly rather than hidden, and a licensed agent at Provident Financial Group can explain why and what alternatives remain.
Frequently asked questions
Are AmTrust Financial and Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) both available through your agency?
Yes. Both are carriers we can present side by side when you request workers' compensation quotes through our agency, alongside the other carriers we can access for your state and class code.
How do AmTrust Financial and Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) compare on AM Best rating?
AmTrust Financial carries an AM Best financial strength rating of A- (Excellent) (as of 2025-10), and Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) carries A++ (Superior) (as of 2025-10). Ratings are for identification only and do not imply an endorsement.
Which should I choose, AmTrust Financial or Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY)?
There is no single best answer. The right carrier depends on your operation, class codes, payroll and how each carrier's underwriting appetite fits your account. Rather than picking one up front, we request quotes from every carrier we can access and show you a ranked comparison so you can decide.
Do I have to choose only one carrier to get a quote?
No. You submit one application and we request quotes from every carrier we can access for your account — including AmTrust Financial and Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) where each carrier's criteria allow it — then present them ranked side by side.
Is AmTrust publicly traded?
No. AmTrust Financial Services went private in 2018 and is privately held today.
What is AmTrust's AM Best rating?
AmTrust Insurance Company and its rated subsidiaries carry an AM Best Financial Strength Rating of A- (Excellent) and a Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating of a- (Excellent), both affirmed October 10, 2025.
Who owns Philadelphia Insurance Companies?
PHLY has been a member of Tokio Marine Group, one of the world's largest insurance groups, since Tokio Marine's 2008 acquisition.
What is PHLY's AM Best rating?
Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company and its pooled affiliate carry an AM Best Financial Strength Rating of A++ (Superior) and a Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating of aa+ (Superior), affirmed October 23, 2025.
Sources
- amtrustfinancial.com — https://amtrustfinancial.com/about-us/history
- ratings.ambest.com — https://ratings.ambest.com/DisclosurePDF.aspx?AMBNum=4778
- news.ambest.com — https://news.ambest.com/newscontent.aspx?refnum=165778
- phly.com — https://www.phly.com/aboutphly
- markets.financialcontent.com — https://markets.financialcontent.com/stocks/article/bizwire-2025-10-23-am-best-affirms-credit-ratings-of-philadelphia-insurance-companies-members
Last reviewed · Reviewed by Provident Financial Group licensed agents
Carrier names are used for identification only; we are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any carrier. Quotes are not offers of insurance; coverage and pricing are determined by each carrier’s underwriting.
US Workers Comp Insure is a brand of Provident Financial Group, a licensed independent insurance agency. NJ resident license; licensed in 23 states — NJ, NY, CT, VT, OH, MI, VA, PA, DE, MD, NC, SC, GA, FL, TX, KY, KS, CA, IN, AZ, DC, MA and NV. State license numbers available on request. We are an independent agency, not an insurer; coverage is underwritten by the issuing carrier and is subject to that policy's terms, conditions, limits and exclusions. Quotes are not offers of insurance, and no coverage is bound until confirmed in writing by a licensed agent. Carrier names are used for identification only; we are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by any carrier named on this site.
View this comparison at https://usworkerscompinsure.com/compare/amtrust-vs-philadelphia-insurance-workers-comp
Compare up to 10 carriers in minutes.
One application goes out to every carrier we can access for your class of business. You get a ranked comparison you can review and purchase online — with a licensed agent available whenever you want one.
Mon–Fri, 8:00am–6:00pm ET · Independent agency licensed in 23 states